Background: An 11-year-old Georgia girl claims that an 8-year-old and two 9-year-old boys kidnapped and raped her, and they have been criminally charged. While the girl sounded credible during the brief CNN interview, there are several elements of the case which call her account into question. To learn more, see my blog post Georgia Child Rape Case Has Some Problems (Part I).
I read this article and watched the video tape and almost fell off my chair. In the story, one of the boys’ fathers said that if there was sex between his son and the girl, it was consensual.
When asked for a response, incredibly, Police Chief Michael Wilkie of Acworth (pictured) told CNN that because children that young cannot legally consent to sex, “we have to go with the charges we have”–in other words, the rape charges. So let’s say that the 11 year-old girl and one of the boys did have consensual sex. Because children cannot legally consent to sex, that means that the girl has been raped and the boy is a rapist? Even though they’re both children? Even though the girl is considerably older than the boy?
The full story is below. The video link is here.
Three boys, 8 and 9, charged with raping 11-year-old girl
CNN, 11/19/07
MARIETTA, Georgia (CNN) — Three boys, ages 8 and 9, were charged Monday with raping an 11-year-old girl last week, court officials and police said.
“Never in my 20-plus years of law enforcement have I conceived of something like this,” Police Chief Michael Wilkie of Acworth, Georgia, told CNN.
Clad in blue jumpsuits, the two 9-year-olds and one 8-year-old appeared in court in Cobb County, north of Atlanta, on Monday afternoon and were ordered to remain in custody until a further hearing. Family members were in court for their appearance, which was closed to reporters.
Wilkie said the girl told investigators she was raped Thursday evening. She was examined by doctors after her family reported the allegation late Saturday, and investigators questioned her extensively on Sunday, he said.
The father of one of the boys told The Associated Press that no force was used against the girl, and said the allegations have been leveled because the accuser “didn’t want to get in trouble with her parents.” Watch chief describe parents’ reactions to charges against their sons »
But Wilkie said children that young cannot legally consent to sex, “so we have to go with the charges we have.” (more…)
