Joyce Carol Oates is one of America’s most famous and successful writers. She has written enthralling stories and novels in a variety of genres. “Come Meet Muffin!†is her first venture into children’s literature.
Unfortunately, she either has no knack for this genre or at least has not developed one. “Come Meet Muffin!†is a tale that does not charm. Its story is awkward and forced and much of the writing is stilted.
The first sentence informs us that, “Muffin is a special kitty who came to live with the Smith family.†Then we learn that when Muffin was a little kitten, he wandered lost and was seen by the Smith family as they were driving by in their car. The daughter of the family, Lily, wanted to take him in and the family did.
There are two other cats in the family who “welcomed Muffin and made him feel at home.†Muffin grows up and displays courtesy in letting “the other cats eat first†as well as courage and intelligence in diverting a strange dog from another cat, and then cleverly climbing a tree to ensure his own safety.
The heart of the story is about his good deed to a pair of fawns who appear to have gotten separated from their mother.
“Come Meet Muffin!†does not seem credible even by the standards of a children’s tale when we are told, “All the birds sang in excitement that Muffin and the fawns were there.†Nor is the tale particularly engaging or interesting.
Illustrator Mark Graham has painted some eye-catching impressionistic oils for the book. An especially cute illustration shows Muffin straining to look up a table. An especially heart-warming picture shows Lily holding him as the other two cats look on.
Other than the pictures, “Come Meet Muffin!†has little to recommend it. Let’s hope that Joyce Carol Oates either polishes her skills for this genre before attempting another children’s book or sticks with the many sorts of writings she does so well.

