The title of this essay is taken from the opening statement in the chapter on rape in war in Susan Brownmiller’s book, “Against Our Will: Men, Women, and Rape.â€ÂÂ
Her sentence in turn follows an excerpt from “War As I Knew It,†the memoirs of General George S. Patton (“Old Blood and Guts). Patton writes, “I told him that although I would do my best to keep such incidents to a minimum there would unquestionably be some raping. I told him that he should forward the details of all such incidents to me so that I could have the offenders properly hanged.â€ÂÂ
Brownmiller in turn writes, “It’s funny about MAN’s attitude toward rape in war. UNQUESTIONABLY there will be some raping. Unconscionable but unquestionable. When men are men, slugging it out, unquestionably there will be some raping.â€ÂÂ
In war, men must “slug it out†in squalor, filth, sustained panic, and horror. They are immersed in brutality, killing and getting killed, watching as their best buddies are torn to pieces and living every second with the knowledge that they could be next.
“Unquestionably,†under the hideous and maddening conditions of war, some men who might live inoffensively in civilian life commit the atrocity of rape.
There are multiple reasons for this but two stand out in my mind.
One is that the conditions of war cause law and order to inevitably collapse. Thus, those men who are the least moral and well-socialized to begin with take advantage of the situation to commit this crime even though they might not have done so within the tighter structure of civilian society.
Another reason is that, under the enforced brutality and terror of war, the aggressive and sexual impulses of some men become confused. Their brutality “spills over†from its officially designated targets – other men in ground combat and specifically other men who are soldiers – onto women and takes a sexualized form.
Susan Brownmiller’s biases blind her to what is extraordinary about the attitude of men to rape in war, at least when we limit it to those men of the modern West who possess official power within its military.
It is truly something to make one pause to realize that the modern American military punished men who raped women with the death sentence. This is especially remarkable when one recalls that at the time Patton wrote — and at the present time — we American women enjoy an exemption from the military draft.
Does this mean that, as far as the male leadership in the modern West are concerned, we women are so very privileged as to enjoy an across-the-board exemption from all horrors of war? Not quite. Women have been injured and killed in every war in which bombs are dropped as nothing is more eminently non-discriminatory than a bomb.
However, rape, unlike bombing, is not something that military leaders in the modern West regard as a horror that is necessary to advance the war effort. Thus, in this one-on-one intimate level, women’s privilege is supposed to hold and the violation of that privilege punished in the most extreme manner.
The true question that Brownmiller completely misses in her fervor to indict all men for the actions of a minority of men, is why would male officials punish men so severely for committing this intimate atrocity against women while at the same time DEMANDING that men participate in the horrors of combat?
Interestingly, and significantly, the very same General Patton who asked to be sent details of rape cases so that he could “have the offenders properly hanged,†possessed not the slightest degree of patience with those men who could not face combat. Patton famously became furious at a male soldier who said he had been sent to the hospital because of his “nerves.†Patton swore at the man, screamed “coward†at him and obscenities, slapped him, and demanded that he be sent to the front lines. (Later, doctors discovered that one reason the man’s “nerves†were so bad was that he had malaria.)
The Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in Europe, General Dwight D. (“Ikeâ€ÂÂ) Eisenhower, demanded that Patton apologize for this outburst of rage and Patton did so.
Nevertheless, General Eisenhower also demanded that men, regardless of their individual temperaments or psychological make-up, must be subjected to the horrors of combat. Eisenhower confirmed the order of execution for desertion of the skinny and timid Pvt. Eddie Slovik.
The modern West has demanded that men expose themselves to the horrors of battle. It has punished with the most extreme severity men who commit rape.
“It’s funny about MAN’s attitude toward rape in war.â€ÂÂ
It really is.

