For most people, I'll assume the title of my article didn't have
any immediate clear meaning. If it weren't for the fact that I just
completed a college seminar on "Race and American Cinema",
it wouldn't have carried any distinct implications for me, either.
But, I have recently spent a semester having one of the uglier sides
of American history hammered into my cranium, sickening detail by
sickening detail, by yet another politically-correct white apologist
professor. But I digress. One of the concepts I learned about in this
class was "Black Americana".
This curious phenomenon began in the postbellum South, where powerfully
racist hatred still lingered in the minds of a defeated white upper
class who regarded the newly emancipated African Americans as a threat
and as the quintessential vile other. No longer able to express this
sentiment with the same consistently overt violence that was once
commonplace (though to be sure, incidences of mob lynchings and killings
were by no means uncommon), these malicious attitudes and beliefs
had to find other outlets into the popular culture. And they did,
in a class of commerical product which came to be known as "Black
Americana".
Black Americana took on many forms, from children's books filled
with limericks about black babies being eaten by crocodiles, to statuettes
of black men with grossly distorted physical features, to extreme
caricatures of African Americans which reflected the prevailing stereotypes
regarding blacks at that time. Toothless dirty shiftless vagrant males,
and grinning overweight females were the images most commonly associated
with African American people. Out of these stereotypes, certain pre-constructed
"roles" emerged that a good number of people believed were
the only ways in which black Americans were capable of living. Among
these stereotypical roles, the following have have been preserved
in Black Americana that has survived to this day as collector's items:
"Sambo":: The typically ignorant, happy-go-lucky,
lazy and fairly incompetent black man. Usually portrayed in a context
of abject poverty which came about as a result of his own laziness.
Shown to be content with only gratification of his baser urges.
"Zip Coon": The comically inept black imitator of
white culture. They were usually depicted trying to mimic the civilized,
refined mannerisms of the white upper class, but always to a humorous
degree of failure.
"Picaninny": The black child. Always creating situations
which endanger their safety, but this was not seen as a bad thing,
but rather something to be laughed at.
"Mami": The docile, subservient black female. Overweight,
ignorant and asexual, she was depicted as accepting her "place"
in society. Some figures say that the Aunt Jemima picture is one of
few Black Americana products that remain in post-Civil Rights Era
mainstream culture.
Eventually, the Civil Rights movement came and went and these caricatures
of black stereotypes fell from popularity as popular attitudes towards
African Americans became less hostile. Now, the few Black Americana
products that remain are merely collector's items. (Note: Search E-Bay
for "Black Americana". You'll find some great examples.)
The nursery rhymes about black children frying in the sun, the images
of black men as lazy and incompetent...have all faded into the pages
of American history, comprising a shameful chapter in our nation's
past.
Now, then. What does this have to do with the Men's Rights movement
and the matter at hand? Well, an astute observer might notice the
same trends at work in contemporary American culture. These same pejorative
images appear with disturbing regularity, only now they target men
and seem to be a symptom of underlying malicious popular sentiment.
Violence against men is seen as not only acceptable, but funny. The
average male is expected to exhibit the same level of base, prurient,
ignorant, incompetent behavior that might have been expected from
a pre-Civil Rights Era black American. Violence against male children
is even explicitly advocated in a certain T-Shirt produced by David
and Goliath, one of which features a young boy fleeing a barrage of
rocks thrown at him. My, my, my. How far we have come since the days
where images of picaninnies fleeing the jaws of alligators were seen
as funny.
Not only this, but stereotypical roles for men as well seem to be
emerging these days, just as they did for black Americans in postbellum
America. These, too, appear to come as a direct result of popular
acceptance of the prevailing stereotypes about men.
The abuser: You've all seen it. The battering husband. The
possessive boyfriend. The drunken father. The man who can't control
his temper because his unenlightened masculinity isn't reigned in
by the Nirvana of the glorified feminine. If you've ever been subjected
to the movie "Enough", the antagonist was a prime example
of this stereotype.
The idiot: Most men are expected to fit this role. The man
who can't change a diaper. The man who can't find directions. The
man who just doesn't get it. Gee, we males sure have taken a slide
in the past 30 years, seeing as we've basically made every significant
contribution to the course history in the previous 10,000.
The dishonest patriarch: Hey, if you can't find specific
incidences of the faceless scapegoat of "patriarchy", why
not just make some up? In movies and TV especially, white male heads
of companies or in positions of power are more often than not portrayed
as corrupt, amoral, and only in their position through acts of dishonesty.
If you've seen the film "Dogma", you'd get a good example
of this from the board of directors for that toy company all being
portrayed as evil sinners except, of course, the one female member,
who is seen as innocent and pure.
The lust-filled loser: We've all seen this. The poor sappy
guy who can't help but be manipulated by a woman's feminine wiles
because, well, all men are slaves to their penises. Right?
The socially inept nerd: Just to cover all the bases, in
case a man does display any sign of intelligence, then there's plan
B where his social skills can be denigrated. Women in our culture
are depicted as having it all...competence, intelligence, social skills,
self-control...men on the other hand are lucky to be portrayed as
having one of these virtues.
The similarities are eerie. A set of stereotypical expectations
of men. The acceptance of violence against men as comical. An overall
sense of hostility towards males that bubbles just below the immediately
observable surface of our culture. The question now is, what will
be done to combat this? We men have the tools to fight back that postbellum
blacks didn't. We have the opportunity to learn from our own history
to avoid repeating the mistakes of the past. It is up to us to make
sure that T-shirts like the ones that sport the logo, "Boys are
stupid, throw rocks at them" will go the same way that Black
Americana did-- exposed for the hateful propaganda that it is, and
relegated to a shameful memory in our nation's past.
Christopher Browne
Christopher Browne is a senior at Stonehill College.