False allegations of rape are far more common than most people imagine.
Take Crossfire co-host Tucker Carlson. He was accused
of raping a woman whom he had never met in a city he had never
visited.
Or William Hetherington, whose wife accused him of spousal rape
during a bitter child custody dispute. Hetherington was imprisoned
in 1985, and to this day is still
awaiting justice.
Or the U Mass student who cut her own face and fabricated a story
of attempted rape because she wanted the university to give higher
priority to protecting
women.
It's too early to be making final pronouncements on the Kobe Bryant
case. But you have to wonder when Bryant's alleged victim was reported
to be "bragging" about Bryant's anatomy at a party two
weeks after the escapade.
Are false allegations of rape isolated incidents in our society?
Eugene Kanin is a professor of sociology at Purdue University. Kanin
tracked all allegations of rapes reported to the police over a 9-year
period in one Midwestern
town. In 41% of the cases, the woman later admitted that the rape
allegation was false.
DNA evidence reveals a somewhat lower figure. According to a 1996
Department of
Justice report, "in about 25% of the sexual assault cases
referred to the FBI,...the primary suspect has been excluded by forensic
DNA testing." This means that one in four rape allegations are
simply bogus.
A man convicted of rape often spends 10 years of his life behind
bars.
But what happens to a woman who makes a false allegation of rape?
Usually, nothing.
In the case of Tucker Carlson, he did not prosecute his accuser
because he did not want his name further linked with the stigmatizing
word, "rape."
The U Mass case is even more revealing. When the truth finally came
out, David Angier, the local assistant district attorney, dismissed
the deception: "If anyone is prosecuted for filing a false report,
then victims of real attacks will be less likely to report them."
Read Mr. Angier's remark a second time.
Because it reveals an underlying belief that better that 10 men
be sent to prison on false accusations of rape, than one true victim
of rape decide to drop the charges.
Mr. Angier's remark echoes a chilling statement made by Catherine
Comins of nearby Vassar College, who made this remark in Time magazine:
"Men who are unjustly accused of rape can sometimes gain from
the experience."
In other words, men can be freely accused of crimes they did not
commit. And a man can be packed off to prison not because he assaulted
a woman, but because he can "gain from the experience."
This is reminiscent of the tactic that Stalin used to purge the
kulaks, the landowners who were driven from their farms not because
of any particular wrong they had committed, but because they were
members of a politically incorrect class.
A generation ago, women who had been truly raped often did not press
charges because of the embarrassment, shame, and fear that their complaint
would be ridiculed. Thankfully, those days are past.
Now, men who have been falsely accused of rape do not seek redress
for the same reasons: embarrassment, shame, and fear that their complaint
will be laughed off.
Those days are still very much with us.
Carey Roberts